Answer Center · Property Taxes: Warwick NY vs. Milford PA

How do property taxes compare between Warwick and Milford?

Jacqueline Kraszewski · Lic Real Estate Salesperson Updated November 13, 2026

Serving Pike & Wayne County, PA · Orange & Sullivan County, NY · PA: RSR004383 · NY: 10401249068

The short answer

Buyers often find that property taxes on the New York side of the border are higher than on comparable homes in Pike County, PA, sometimes by a meaningful amount. But there is no reliable shortcut based on purchase price alone: the best comparison is always the actual tax bill for the specific property.

Buyers often find that property taxes on the New York side of the border are higher than on comparable homes in Pike County, PA, sometimes by a meaningful amount. But there is no reliable shortcut based on purchase price alone. The best comparison is always the actual tax bill for the specific property you are considering.

Warwick, NY

Warwick, NY: Property owners may have school, county and town taxes, and homes located within the Village of Warwick also have village taxes. School taxes are a significant part of the overall bill. Qualified owners of a primary residence may also be eligible for New York's STAR benefit. For new homeowners, this is generally the STAR credit, rather than the older STAR exemption program. The STAR benefit applies to school taxes only.

One additional Warwick closing cost

One additional Warwick closing cost: Certain real estate transfers in the Town of Warwick are also subject to a one-time Community Preservation/PDR transfer tax at closing. This is separate from the property's annual real estate taxes, so buyers should account for it when estimating their total cash needed to close.

Milford and Pike County, PA

Milford and Pike County, PA: Properties may have county, municipal and school district taxes, depending on the exact location. Homes in the Milford area are generally within the Delaware Valley School District. Buyers often find the overall annual property-tax burden lower than on similarly priced homes across the border in Orange County, but the actual bill can vary significantly from property to property.

The most important thing to know

The most important thing to know: Don't compare taxes using list price or a headline tax rate alone. Look at the property's current assessed value and the actual annual tax bills, including school, county and municipal taxes. A lower tax rate applied to a different assessment does not necessarily mean a lower tax bill.

How I compare homes

When I am helping a buyer compare homes, I look at the actual taxes for each property so we can compare the real monthly carrying cost, not just the purchase price.

Property taxes, compared

Warwick, NYMilford, PA
Taxing bodies School, county and town taxes; village taxes for homes within the Village of Warwick County, municipal and school district taxes, depending on the exact location
School taxes A significant part of the overall bill Milford-area homes are generally within the Delaware Valley School District
Exemptions Qualified owners of a primary residence may be eligible for New York's STAR benefit, which applies to school taxes only None noted in the comparison
Overall burden Often higher than on comparable homes in Pike County, sometimes by a meaningful amount Often lower than on similarly priced homes across the border in Orange County, but the actual bill can vary significantly
One-time transfer tax Certain real estate transfers in the Town of Warwick are subject to a Community Preservation/PDR transfer tax at closing None noted in the comparison
How to compare Look at the current assessed value and the actual annual tax bills, including school, county and municipal taxes Same approach: the actual bill, not list price or a headline tax rate alone

Regardless of which side of the PA–NY border you're considering, I'll help you understand the numbers and where to verify the current tax information for the property.

Source: My Warwick and Milford neighborhood guides. General information, not legal or tax advice: real estate laws, rates, and practices change, and every transaction is different. Verify current figures and requirements with a qualified real estate attorney, tax professional, lender, or the local taxing authority before acting on anything here.