Neighborhood Guide · Pike County, Pennsylvania
Living in Conashaugh Lakes.
A private, gated lake community in the Milford and Dingmans Ferry area of Pike County, Pennsylvania, set on roughly 1,000 wooded acres around Seneca Lake and Conashaugh Lake.
Conashaugh Lakes at a Glance - Community Amenities
Seneca Lake & Conashaugh Lake
The two lakes sit at the center of the community. Both offer fishing and access for non-powerboats, which keeps the water suited to canoes, kayaks, and quiet afternoons rather than motor traffic.
Seasonal Outdoor Pool
A seasonal outdoor swimming pool is part of the community's shared recreation. Like most outdoor amenities in the region, it operates seasonally, so confirm current hours, rules, and any fees with the association.
Tennis & Basketball Courts
Outdoor tennis and basketball courts give residents places to play without leaving the community.
Volleyball & Bocce Courts
Volleyball and bocce courts add casual, low-key options for groups of any size.
Baseball Field
A community baseball field rounds out the recreation, with open space for pick-up games.
Gated Access & Private Roads
The community is private and gated, and its roads are maintained by the community association rather than the township.
Homes & Properties
Homes in Conashaugh Lakes are single-family residences set on properties of at least one acre, giving the community a more spacious, wooded feel. Homes vary in age, size, and style, and the setting can feel different from one property to the next.
When considering a home here, it’s also important to look beyond the property itself and think about whether the community fits the way you want to live. If having more space and privacy appeals to you, but you still like the idea of lakes and recreational amenities nearby, Conashaugh Lakes offers both. The community’s amenities, along with its rules, roads, and dues, are all part of deciding whether it feels like the right fit.
What Buyers Should Know
Buying in a private community is different from buying outside one. Beyond the house itself, you are buying into a set of shared roads, amenities, rules, and fees, so it pays to understand them before you make an offer.
Community dues
Association dues exist, and amounts vary from property to property. Confirm the current dues for the specific home you are considering with the Conashaugh Lakes Community Association.
Rules and regulations
The community maintains its own rules and regulations, known as the association's Blue Book, along with deed restrictions. These govern things like property use, rentals, and exterior changes, so it is worth reading them before you buy.
Private roads
Roads inside the community are private and are maintained by the community association rather than the township.
Shared amenities
The lakes, pool, courts, and ball field are shared community facilities. Confirm how they are accessed and whether any fees apply.
Wells and septic
Homes in this area commonly use private wells and septic systems. Confirm the setup for the specific property you are considering.
Rental policies
Rental policies are set by the community association and can change. Verify the current policy directly with the association before relying on it.
Resale documents
Ask for and review the community's resale and disclosure documents before purchasing, and have your own advisors review them as well.
Gate and security
The community is gated, and gate and security procedures apply. Confirm how access works for residents, guests, and service providers.
Conashaugh Lakes Community Association
102 Conashaugh Trail, Milford, PA 18337
Conashaugh Lakes Community Association (conashaughlakes.com)
Use the association website to verify current dues, rules, rental policies, and amenities.
Office hours: Monday-Friday 8am-4pm, Saturday 8am-12pm
Location & What's Nearby
Conashaugh Lakes is in the Milford and Dingmans Ferry area of Pike County, Pennsylvania, in the northeast corner of the Pocono Mountains. The community is within reach of the Delaware Water Gap National Recreation Area, which brings hiking, canoeing, and large stretches of open space to the region.
Route 739 runs through the area, and the community is convenient to both New Jersey and New York, which makes it a practical option for weekend and second-home buyers. The community is part of the Delaware Valley School District, headquartered in Milford.
The surrounding region is known for its outdoor recreation, and the Delaware Water Gap National Recreation Area is the anchor of that.
For information on the area, visit AroundHereGuide.com.
Frequently Asked Questions
What school district services Conashaugh Lakes?
Homes in this community are served by the Delaware Valley School District.
GreatSchools provides independent school information and ratings based on factors including student progress, test scores, and college readiness. Ratings can change as new data becomes available.
GreatSchools Rating: 7/10 (as of October 2026)
Explore school information and current ratings on GreatSchools
Are Short-Term Rentals allowed?
What are the HOA dues and or community fees?
Thinking About a Home in Conashaugh Lakes?
I work with buyers and sellers throughout Pike County and can help you understand not only the house, but the community that comes with it. If you're comparing Conashaugh Lakes with other communities in the Milford and Dingmans Ferry area, I can help you understand the differences.
Jacqueline Kraszewski
Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Pocono Real Estate
PA License: RSR004383 · NY License: 10401249068