Answer Center · Property Taxes: Warwick NY vs. Milford PA
What should I consider when buying a second home or vacation property?
Serving Pike & Wayne County, PA · Orange & Sullivan County, NY · PA: RSR004383 · NY: 10401249068
The short answer
Start with how you plan to use the home, then look at the total carrying cost, not just the purchase price. Taxes, insurance, utilities, maintenance, well and septic upkeep, and any rental rules all matter for a property you won't live in full time.
Both Milford and Warwick attract buyers looking for a weekend getaway or second home within reach of the New York metro area, but buying a property you won't live in full time comes with some additional things to think about.
Start with how you plan to use the home
Start with how you plan to use the home. Is this strictly a place for you to enjoy, somewhere you may eventually live full time, or a property you hope to rent when you're not using it? The answer can affect everything from the type of property you buy to financing, insurance and where you should look.
Consider the total carrying cost, not just the purchase price
Consider the total carrying cost, not just the purchase price. property taxes can differ significantly between Orange County, NY and Pike County, PA. You'll also want to budget for insurance, utilities, heating, maintenance, snow removal and other expenses that continue whether you're at the property or not.
Well and septic systems are common
Well and septic systems are common. Many properties in and around Milford and Warwick have private wells and septic systems. If you're buying a home that will sit vacant for periods of time, it's important to understand the condition and maintenance requirements of those systems before you buy.
If you plan to rent the property, check the rules before making an offer
If you plan to rent the property, check the rules before making an offer. Short-term rental regulations vary by municipality, township and community. Some HOAs or private communities may have additional rental restrictions. Never assume that because a property is currently being used as a short-term rental, you'll automatically be able to continue using it that way.
Financing and insurance can be different for a second home
Financing and insurance can be different for a second home. Loan programs, down-payment requirements, interest rates and insurance can differ depending on whether the property will be your primary residence, a true second home or an investment property. Talk with your lender and insurance professional early so you know how the property will be classified.
Think about the property when you're not there
Think about the property when you're not there. Heating and winterization, storm damage, fallen trees, snow removal, security and routine maintenance become more important when a home may sit unattended for days or weeks at a time.
The right second home
The right second home isn't just about finding a house you love. It's about finding a property that works for the way you actually plan to use it and understanding the ongoing costs and responsibilities before you buy.
Ongoing costs to budget for a second home
| Item | What to know |
|---|---|
| Property taxes | Can differ significantly between Orange County, NY and Pike County, PA |
| Insurance, utilities, heating | Continue whether you're at the property or not |
| Maintenance and snow removal | Continue whether you're at the property or not |
| Well and septic upkeep | Common on properties in and around Milford and Warwick; understand condition and maintenance requirements before you buy |
| Short-term rental rules | Vary by municipality, township and community; some HOAs or private communities add restrictions |
If you're considering a second home in Milford, Warwick or the surrounding area, I'll help you compare the properties, taxes, communities and practical considerations so you can decide what makes the most sense for you.
Resources
A note from Jacqueline
I have lived on both sides of this equation, and I know a weekend house is wonderful when the numbers make sense and stressful when they don't. Tell me how you actually want to use the property, and I'll point you to the right places and the right questions to ask. Let me know if you need anything or have any questions.
Source: My service area guides. General information, not legal or tax advice: real estate laws, rates, and practices change, and every transaction is different. Verify current figures and requirements with a qualified real estate attorney, tax professional, lender, or the local taxing authority before acting on anything here.